RCS Leadership Lounge

The Power of Belonging: Why It Matters for Your Team — and Why It Must Start on Day One

Written by Christy Benitez | Dec 12, 2025 12:00:00 PM


Belonging isn’t soft.
It’s not “nice-to-have.”
And it’s not an HR buzzword that gets dusted off during performance review season.

Belonging is foundational, a core human need woven into our biology. Long before performance metrics, SOPs, or mission statements, human beings were gathering around fires, forming tribes, and looking for the signal every nervous system still craves:

You’re safe here. You matter here. You belong here. We got your back.

Fast-forward a few thousand years and the landscape looks different. Fewer woolly mammoths, more Wi-Fi. But the wiring hasn’t changed. Our teams are made up of people whose brains and bodies depend on connection, acceptance, and community to thrive.

And this is where the story of belonging becomes very relevant to leaders, managers, supervisors, and anyone who cares about culture:

If you want your team to stay, contribute, grow, and give the kind of discretionary effort that can’t be bought… belonging is the soil it grows in. (I’m a plant lover so this makes sense to me.)

Belonging as a Human Need (And Why Your Team Feels It at Work)

Modern research continues to affirm what our ancestors already understood: when people feel accepted and valued, their entire system operates differently. Belonging improves:

  • Psychological well-being
  • Confidence and self-esteem
  • Stress regulation
  • Creativity and contribution
  • Loyalty and emotional commitment

A team member who feels like they belong isn’t simply “happier.”
They are safer, emotionally and psychologically. And safety unlocks a magical performance.

On the flip side, the absence of belonging takes a toll. The human brain experiences exclusion as a threat (insert mental image of a giant tiger staring you down as you walk through the doors of the club each day). People shut down, withdraw, stop offering ideas, and start scanning the horizon for the nearest exit (or competitor).

Why Belonging Is the Culture Strategy Most Leaders Overlook

If you want a thriving, connected, high-performing team, belonging is your secret advantage. It influences retention more powerfully than pay alone, shapes how openly people communicate, and determines whether team members feel safe enough to contribute their talents fully.

Here’s the part leaders often underestimate:

People give their discretionary effort — the passion, the pride, the “let me fix that before anyone notices” energy — only to things and places they feel connected to.

No one pours their best into a culture that feels cold, chaotic, or indifferent.

But give them belonging?
Watch them light up. Watch them give the best of themselves without being asked.

Belonging Starts Early — Earlier Than You Think

Most leaders assume belonging develops over time. Weeks. Months. Relationships built slowly.

On the contrary…

Belonging begins the moment someone says yes to joining your team, and it’s cemented (or shattered) in the first few days.

The onboarding experience is your culture’s first impression. And just like with any first impression, people remember how you made them feel far longer than they remember a checklist or slideshow.

A powerful onboarding experience tells your newest team members:

  • You’re not the new kid — you’re part of us now.
  • Your voice matters.
  • We hired you for your magic.
  • Your perspective is welcome here.
  • We’re invested in you, not just your output.

Early belonging is one of the strongest predictors of long-term retention. When someone feels anchored from day one, the commitment deepens. When early signals of belonging are missing, people mentally keep their bags packed.

Belonging Is the Heartbeat of a Healthy Culture

A culture without belonging might function, but it won’t flourish. It will feel transactional, inconsistent, and fragile.

A culture infused with belonging feels entirely different:

Warm.
Aligned.
Grounded.
Human.

It’s the kind of culture where people look out for each other, where talent stays, where communication is open, and where team members choose to go the extra mile not because they have to… but because they want to.

Belonging is the root system of a thriving environment (again with the plant metaphor).

5 Ways to Create Belonging From Day One

Since belonging is essential, the real question becomes: How do we cultivate it intentionally?

Here are five practical, powerful ways to help every new team member feel like they truly belong — from their very first day:

  1. Make Their Arrival Feel Like an Event, Not an Afterthought

A warm welcome sets the tone. A personal note, a prepared workspace, or a team introduction sends a clear message:
We’ve been expecting you. We’re glad you’re here.

  1. Pair Them With a Culture Guide or Onboarding Buddy

Someone to answer questions, share unwritten norms, and help them feel connected from the start. Social support accelerates belonging more than any manual ever could.

  1. Tell the Story of Your Culture — Early and Often

New team members need to understand not just what you do, but why you do it and who you are.
Share your mission, your values, your history, your quirks. This gives them something to root into. Show them how their role ties directly to the mission and how their presence impacts the experience.

  1. Ask About Their Strengths and Talents — Then Use Them Immediately

Belonging grows when people feel needed. Show them that their gifts and talents matter and that they weren’t hired to fill a slot — they were hired to elevate a team.

  1. Invite Their Voice — and Actually Listen

The fastest path to belonging is contribution. Ask what they see, what they wonder, what ideas they have. New team members often have the clearest eyes. Value that clarity and tap into it early!

Final Thought

Belonging is the quiet force behind thriving teams.
It’s what keeps people rooted.
It’s what inspires their best work.
And it’s what transforms a workplace from a place you go to work to a place you’re excited to be a part of.

Lead with belonging, especially in those first critical days, and you’ll build something far stronger than a team.

You’ll build a impactful community where joy and fulfillment bloom!

###

About the Author: Christy Benitez

Christy Benitez is a recognized leader in the fields of hospitality, coaching, and teambuilding. With a proven track record in leadership development, talent optimization, and operational excellence, Christy brings a wealth of expertise to RCS Hospitality Group.Christy is a dynamic leadership coach and true people enthusiast. She leverages her hands-on experience to harmonize business priorities with organizational strategies.In her previous role as Director of Talent, Development, and Culture at a private club, Christy excelled in aligning business objectives with talent strategy. She not only developed service standards but also spearheaded and facilitated training programs, fostering a culture of growth. During challenging times, Christy's leadership played a pivotal part in creating new roles and supporting internal promotions, all while maintaining high employee engagement and retention rates.Christy is a certified practitioner with The Working Genius and is dedicated to helping individuals and organizations realize their true potential, enhancing organizational efficiency, and maximizing production and engagement.