In the hospitality industry, hiring has evolved. While technical skills and experience remain important, today’s top club leaders are increasingly focused on something less tangible, but far more powerful: culture.
Across the industry, General Managers, executive leaders, and hiring committees consistently express a similar theme when discussing talent. Skills can be developed, systems can be learned, but mindset, emotional intelligence, and cultural alignment are far harder to teach.
In a hospitality environment built on relationships and service, the people we bring into our teams shape everything, from the member experience to the morale of the staff. The best leaders understand that hiring decisions are about strengthening culture.
What Leaders Want in Senior Leadership Candidates
When hiring for senior roles like an Assistant General Manager, an Executive Chef, a Director of Golf, Clubhouse Manager, or a Department Head, today’s club leaders are looking for individuals who can elevate operations and their most important asset, the team.
They Want: Cultural Ambassadors
Senior leaders embody the club’s culture and values. They understand that their behavior sets the tone for their department and influences the entire team. Leaders who demonstrate humility, accountability, and a genuine service mindset help create stability and trust within the organization.
They Don’t Want: “Resume Managers”
Technical competence alone is no longer enough. Leaders who rely solely on past titles or credentials without demonstrating empathy, collaboration, or emotional intelligence often struggle in club environments where teamwork and relationships drive success.
They Want: Collaborative Thinkers
Clubs operate through interdependent departments. Golf, Food & Beverage, Membership, Facilities, and Administration all intersect in delivering the member experience. Leaders who actively communicate across departments and prioritize shared success create stronger operational flow.
They Don’t Want: Departmental Silos
A technically strong leader who isolates their team or competes with other departments can undermine the culture of the club. Leaders who focus only on their own success often create friction rather than synergy.
They Want: Coaches, Not Commanders
The most respected club leaders today see themselves as mentors. They invest in developing supervisors and frontline employees, recognizing that strong teams produce consistent service.
They Don’t Want: Authority Without Engagement
Leaders who manage strictly through hierarchy, issuing directives without listening or guiding, often struggle to build loyalty. Clubs thrive when leaders are approachable, present, and engaged with their teams.
What Leaders Want in Mid-Level Leadership
Mid-level leaders, including supervisors, managers, and emerging department heads, play a critical role in daily operations. They translate strategy into action and influence the employee experience more than almost anyone else.
They Want: Reliability and Ownership
Great supervisors take responsibility for outcomes. They anticipate challenges, communicate clearly with their teams, and follow through on commitments.
They Don’t Want: Excuses or Blame
Managers who deflect responsibility or attribute issues solely to others rarely build strong teams. Accountability is a defining characteristic of effective leadership.
They Want: Emotional Intelligence
In hospitality, every shift brings moments of pressure, including member concerns, service breakdowns, and interpersonal challenges. Leaders who remain calm, empathetic, and solutions-focused help stabilize teams during demanding moments.
They Don’t Want: Technical Perfection Without People Skills
A manager who excels in systems but struggles to communicate respectfully or support their team will ultimately weaken the culture. Employees want to work for leaders who treat them with fairness and dignity.
They Want: Curiosity and Growth
The strongest emerging leaders ask questions, seek mentorship, and pursue learning opportunities. They understand that leadership development is an ongoing process.
They Don’t Want: Complacency
Managers who believe they already have all the answers rarely grow. Clubs benefit most from individuals who remain curious and open to improvement.
The Balance Between Skill and Mindset
Technical ability still matters. A culinary leader must understand kitchen operations, a golf professional must know the game, and a membership director must be skilled in relationship-building.
However, most club leaders agree on a fundamental truth: operational tactics can be taught more easily than attitude and cultural alignment.
Training programs, mentorship, and structured onboarding can develop technical skills. But qualities such as integrity, empathy, humility, and optimism are often deeply rooted in a person’s character.
That is why many hiring leaders begin interviews not by asking about systems or processes, but by exploring how candidates think, lead, and interact with others.
What HR Expertise Tells Us
Human resources research across industries reinforces what many club leaders already observe. Studies consistently show that organizations with strong cultural alignment experience higher employee engagement, stronger retention, and more consistent performance.
HR professionals often emphasize three key qualities when evaluating candidates:
Self-awareness. Candidates who understand their strengths and areas for growth are more receptive to feedback.
Adaptability. Hospitality environments require flexibility and resilience. Leaders must respond to change without losing focus or composure.
Service orientation. Individuals who genuinely enjoy helping others create stronger connections with members and coworkers alike.
These qualities are difficult to train but invaluable to long-term success.
The Fresh Perspective: Hiring for Energy
Energy is contagious. A manager who approaches challenges with optimism can uplift an entire team. Conversely, negativity spreads quickly and undermines morale.
This shift toward hiring for energy reflects a broader understanding of workplace culture. Teams do not execute tasks; they create environments and memorable moments.
The Takeaway
Hiring decisions shape the future of a club. While experience and technical knowledge remain important, today’s top club leaders place greater emphasis on character, emotional intelligence, and cultural alignment.
Hospitality is ultimately about people.
They seek individuals who collaborate, communicate openly, and invest in the growth of others. They value leaders who bring both competence and humility, and who recognize that hospitality is ultimately about people.
When clubs prioritize these qualities, they build teams capable of delivering excellent service and lasting loyalty from members and employees alike.
And in the end, that is what great leadership and great clubs are truly about.
###
About the Author: Paige Frazier